Rent Repayment Orders – better treatment for landlords in future?

Rent Repayment Orders – better treatment for landlords in future?


Todays other news
Northern cities are set to outpace the south for the...
A sustainable energy consultant gives tips that really work -...
The views of expert working for Stacks Property Search, a...


A recent judgement may mean that future Rent Repayment Orders may be less severe than those in the past.

Many Rent Repayment Orders in recent years have appeared to default to demanding the landlord repay 100 per cent of the rent in a period – but a judge has now given First Tier Property Tribunals new guidance suggesting discretion could be used, without the entirety of the rent being the starting point for a settlement.

Instead, a decision in a recent appeal case to the Upper Tribunal – Acheampong v Roman & Ors and Choudhury v Razak & Ors – has set a new guidance for RROs. 

This means the order should take into consideration the full rent minus the cost of utilities, and in addition the RRO should take into consideration the offence’s seriousness compared to similar offences. 

It should then ask what proportion of the rent would be a fair reflection of these combined factors.

Sarah Cummins, a rent and landlord legal expert at the Anthony Gold law practice, says: “The guidance is helpful and should put an end to the practice of taking the full rent as the starting point and making deductions based on the statutory factors. 

“While it had already been confirmed in [an earlier case] Williams v Parmar that this was the wrong approach, [the judge]’s methodology should assist tribunals with their assessments particularly with ensuring the seriousness of the offence is properly considered before determining the starting point for the RRO.

“Whether this will lead to more consistent RRO awards is a different matter. 

“The Tribunal will need to evaluate the factors in the individual case and reach a conclusion on where on the scale of seriousness the offence lies. No doubt there will be differing views on this and future appeals may revolve around whether the tribunal has carried out that assessment correctly.”

You can read a more detailed account of the case and judgement that may lead to rethinking RROs here.

Tags:

Share this article ...

Join the conversation: Login and have your say

Want to comment on this story? Our focus is on providing a platform for you to share your insights and views and we welcome contributions. All comments are screened using specialist software and may be reviewed by our editorial team before publication. Landlord Today reserves the right to edit, withhold or delete comments that violate our guidelines, including those that harass, degrade, or intimidate others. Users who post such content may be banned from commenting.
By commenting, you agree to our Commenting Terms of Use.
Recommended for you
Related Articles
The tenant was in hospital when he was evicted illegally...
The controversial proposal is backed by the Welsh Government...
Growing arrears, falling yields and new laws make 2025 a...
Recommended for you
Latest Features
Northern cities are set to outpace the south for the...
A sustainable energy consultant gives tips that really work -...
The views of expert working for Stacks Property Search, a...
Sponsored Content

Send to a friend

In order to send this article to a friend you must first login. Click on the button below to login or sign up.

No one likes pop-ups ...
But while you're here