As we head into the Autumn Budget next week, it’s been eerily quiet with regards to housing policy and landlords.
Compared with previous Budgets under the current Government, when there was more kite flying than the Portsmouth International Kite Festival, this year has been relatively silent.
The perennial changes to Capital Gains Tax have been raised by various think tanks, as has a reduced Mansion Tax threshold, although both have been dismissed.
On the one hand, the lack of kite flying is positive and massively welcome. As lenders, we have regularly seen pipelines stymied by the clumsy leaking of policy to test the waters, most of which actually ends up on the cutting room floor.
These leaks influence behaviour; just ask the financial advisors who have been pulling their hair out as clients made big pension decisions on the back of rumour. We have seen it in the form of landlords delaying purchases, or withdrawing from transactions completely over fears of what the Chancellor may say at the dispatch box.
However, with my suspicious hat on, I can’t help but feel the Chancellor will pull a rabbit out of the hat and hit the market with yet another surprise. We have seen it a couple of times before – Rachel Reeves upping the Stamp Duty surcharge in 2024, following that up with the two percentage point increase in Income Tax from property income last year.
It’s not all Labour, however. Jeremy Hunt used his final Budget to abolish multiple dwellings relief on Stamp Duty, although he did cut Capital Gains Tax on residential property, which was more welcome.
While the threat of further measures aimed at landlords hang over us, I repeat something that is becoming a mantra more recently. You cannot keep playing ‘Buckaroo!’ with landlords, adding more tax and policy until the horse buckles or kicks out.
We are already seeing the layering of numerous fiscal and policy changes over the past decade affecting rental housing provision in this country.
Zoopla’s latest rental report shows that rental availability is 25% below its pre-pandemic level, while RICS’ UK Residential Market Survey’s landlord instructions indicator has been in negative territory since mid-2022 and has been trending downwards since 2014.
While still far from an exodus, the days of strong growth in the size of the private rented sector are clearly over, and that will be to the detriment of tenants. Population and household formation are forecast to increase strongly over the coming decade and without a correlating increase in transient housing provision, I worry that tenants will be the people who lose out.
Figures from UK Finance this week showed there were just over 16,000 properties purchased with a buy-to-let mortgage during the second quarter this year, a figure consistent with the quarterly pattern since the start of 2024.
However, this is 5,000 below the average quarterly run-rate since 2013, and a shortage of new rental supply will only exacerbate the supply demand imbalance within the rental market.
We know this is a difficult Budget for John Healy, who has the unenviable balancing task of raising revenue without undermining economic growth. But my message to him is that landlords have experienced too much change in too short a period and further measures now could cause more harm than good.
I’m not expecting a Halloween horror show, but I will still be watching through my fingers – and hoping the Chancellor resists another frightening surprise for the sector.
Louisa Sedgwick is Managing Director of Mortgages at Paragon Bank