Landlord Natter: Numbers don’t add up over new PRS homes claim

Landlord Natter: Numbers don’t add up over new PRS homes claim


Todays other news
It's just one of many demands from the Generation Rent...
It's another push to improve private rental sector energy efficiency...
Individual landlords are quitting and big companies moving in...
The analysis has been undertaken by a finance firm...
Landlord Natter logo with orange background and bold text.

Apparently, there will be another half a million households renting privately in England by 2035.

That’s according to government projections accompanying plans to extend Awaab’s Law to the private rented sector.

Advertisement

Judging by your reaction to the story, some of you are wondering where on earth all these additional rental homes are going to come from. And I can understand why.

Advertisement

Jo Westlake recalls that, back in 2019–20, she was planning to expand her portfolio. Mortgage rates were attractive and the Renters’ Rights Act wasn’t even on the horizon.

Advertisement

Today, she says, the prospect of further investment has lost its appeal. Her husband would happily sell the lot, although they’re concerned about what might happen to their tenants.

Andy Marshall is already selling. Peter Roberts, who once had 11 properties, is down to two still rented, with another sale agreed.

Advertisement

Hardly the sound of an industry gearing up for expansion.

But here’s a thought. What if the government is right?

Advertisement

Or, more precisely, what if the landlords predicting a difficult future for their businesses are right, too?

The two positions aren’t necessarily contradictory.

The government is forecasting an increase in privately renting households, not an increase in the number of private landlords. Indeed, its own assessment acknowledges uncertainty about future landlord numbers and raises the possibility of consolidation.

And that’s where things become interesting.

Build to Rent developments are gradually adding new homes, backed by institutional investors and pension funds. Meanwhile, some traditional landlords are expanding through limited companies, adopting a more corporate approach themselves.

Others are selling, of course. But a reduction in the number of landlords doesn’t necessarily mean a reduction in rental properties.

There’s also the government’s substantial programme for building social and affordable homes. Social renting is counted separately from the PRS, but additional social housing could ease some of the pressure on private rentals.

So we could end up with fewer individual landlords, more professionally managed properties and a larger overall rental housing stock.

Which brings me to our second story.

Research suggests that landlords are increasingly turning to letting agents to cope with the additional responsibilities accompanying the Renters’ Rights Act.

A JR points out that employing an agent doesn’t remove a landlord’s ultimate responsibility. Michael Foley wonders why landlords should pay substantial fees when the buck still stops with them.

But johnmhughes offers a useful comparison. He employs an accountant to prepare his tax returns. HMRC still holds him responsible for any mistakes, but he’d rather trust somebody who understands the rules.

Robert Shread provides the qualification. He uses two agents, one excellent, the other a source of concern because of poor communication.

Professional management, it seems, is only as good as the professionals involved.

And it costs money. Michael worries about fees and VAT, while Neil Moores predicts higher rents. But johnmhughes reminds us that landlords cannot simply pass on every additional expense. Tenants have budgets and local markets impose limits.

Which takes us back to that half-million forecast.

The question isn’t simply whether Britain will need more rented homes. It’s who will provide them, what they’ll cost and whether they’ll be the right sort of homes in the right places.

A purpose-built apartment in a city centre isn’t necessarily a replacement for a family house in a market town. Nor does a change of ownership automatically create an additional property.

And while larger landlords may achieve economies of scale, they still have to make their investments pay.

Perhaps the private rented sector of 2035 will look very different from the one we know today.

Perhaps there will be fewer landlords, but more rental homes.

Perhaps some of today’s smaller landlords will become tomorrow’s larger operators.

Or perhaps the government’s projections will prove optimistic.

What strikes me is that the landlords commenting on these stories are describing the decisions they’re making today, while the government is attempting to describe a market nearly a decade away.

Both deserve to be heard.

After all, you can forecast demand for another half a million rented homes.

Persuading somebody to provide them is quite another matter.

Until next time,

N

Share this article ...

Join the conversation: Login and have your say

Want to comment on this story? Our focus is on providing a platform for you to share your insights and views and we welcome contributions. All comments are screened using specialist software and may be reviewed by our editorial team before publication. Landlord Today reserves the right to edit, withhold or delete comments that violate our guidelines, including those that harass, degrade, or intimidate others. Users who post such content may be banned from commenting.
By commenting, you agree to our Commenting Terms of Use.
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Recommended for you
Related Articles
Landlord Natter logo with orange background and bold text.
Property Natter explores conflicting landlord statistics, questioning whether rental profits,...
Landlord Natter logo with orange background and bold text.
Landlords warn that Budget tax hikes could push up rents,...
Miniature houses with property tax crossword tiles on wooden surface.
Landlord Natter logo with orange background and bold text.
Landlords face difficult choices over when to invest as energy...
The analysis comes from Rightmove...
Often has launched a controversial consultation...
Recommended for you
Latest Features
Virelle Group forecasts rising rents, shorter tenancies and changing seasonal...
Property Natter explores conflicting landlord statistics, questioning whether rental profits,...
The author is founder and chief executive of a residential...
Sponsored Content
Property investment is a long-term strategy, but that doesn't mean...
The Renters’ Rights Act has sparked widespread discussion around rent...
Thinking About Selling Your Rental Property? Five Things Landlords Should...

Send to a friend

In order to send this article to a friend you must first login. Click on the button below to login or sign up.