By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies to enhance your experience.
Graham Awards


Landlord fined after failing to provide safety certificates

A landlord has been fined for failing to ensure that gas fittings, appliances and associated flues were checked for safety.

Edinburgh Sheriffs Court heard that from late winter 2013 to early spring 2014. David Mackman stated he was the landlord for at least 15 flats in an old tenement block.

The majority of the flats had gas central heating boilers for heating and hot water. Some of the boilers served more than one flat. 


The court was told tenants were not provided with Landlord’s Gas Safety Certificates.

The Health and Safety Executive investigated after receiving a complaint from a tenant. The HSE inspector failed to obtain a response from Mr Mackman and on being unable to contact the complainant attended the block of flats with another HSE inspector.

The inspectors gained access to several flats and quickly identified gas safety concerns.  

They again attempted to make contact the landlord during this visit but failed.  Due to the gas safety concerns the inspectors decided to contact the Gas Safe Register, the official gas safety organisation in Britain, who arranged for Scottish Gas Networks to attend the property.

The inspectors later revisited the property with SGN engineers and after gaining access to further flats they identified further gas safety faults. SGN issued ‘immediately dangerous’ safety notices and disconnected the gas supply to several properties.

Despite repeated attempts to contact him, the landlord did not attend the flats to assist with the investigation.

At a later visit SGN notices were again issued to a number of flats. Mr Mackman attended during this visit and HSE Inspectors issued 15 Improvement Notices.  The aim of the notices was to ensure all gas safety issues were identified and rectified by  a competent Gas Safe registered engineer which would enable the landlord to provide tenants with a Landlord’s Gas Safety Certificate.

David Stuart Mackman from Kirknewton pleaded guilty to breaching Regulation 36(3)(b) of the Gas (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998 and was fined £4,500 and ordered to pay a£175 Victim Surcharge.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Katherine Gostick said:  “It was very fortunate that Mr Mackman’s failure to carry out important landlord gas safety checks did not result in a number of deaths in the flats he rented out, where the unsafe gas appliances were leaking poisonous odour free fumes.

“He should have employed a competent Gas Safe Registered engineer to carry out landlord gas safety checks including carrying out the necessary work and obtain a landlord gas safety certificate every 12 months. 

“Landlords may be prosecuted if they do not ensure that this well publicised duty is carried out. Tenants should check that they receive a landlord gas safety certificate on moving into rented property and annually.”

Want to comment on this story? Our focus is on providing a platform for you to share your insights and views and we welcome contributions.
If any post is considered to victimise, harass, degrade or intimidate an individual or group of individuals, then the post may be deleted and the individual immediately banned from posting in future.
Please help us by reporting comments you consider to be unduly offensive so we can review and take action if necessary. Thank you.

  • icon

    Problems do not go away by ignoring them, it's called '' sweeping them under the carpet'', the sooner a problem is attended to the better for all concerned .

  • icon

    Of Course the LL should have had Safety Certificates.
    It was a complaint from a Tenant to HSE but then remained uncontactable I wonder why ?. I can’t understand why the LL would be uncontactable 15 Flats occupants must have his details and he had previously attended Court. The HSE were able to access multiple flats because I suspect the doors were open wide, a far cry from when the LL wants access.

  • Paul  Conway - Yuno CEO

    Yuno is a great platform to help landlords avoid these hefty fines. Our team can help you identify what you need to do to reduce the risk of non-compliance and maximise the potential of your investment.

  • Ferey Lavassani

    For a change is David Mackman. Usually is Amjad Husain or Tariq Ali.


    But of course he could have changed his name to David Mackman

  • Ferey Lavassani

    Never thought of that Andrew !!!


Please login to comment

MovePal MovePal MovePal
sign up