An analysis of every rent tribunal decision in England since the Renters Rights Act took effect finds most landlords losing part of their increase through thin evidence.
And London landlords are nearly three times as likely as those elsewhere to lose the case entirely through avoidable errors in the notice.
The analysis has been undertaken by online agency Hello Neighbour.
Landlords whose rent increases were challenged at tribunal asked for a median rise of 10.0% and were awarded a median of 6.2%, according to the study of all 336 decisions published in England under the new market rent procedure between May 1 and November 11 2026.
The median landlord kept two-thirds of the increase they had proposed.
Of the 300 decisions that set a rent, the rent went up in 237 (79%), but only 105 landlords (35%) were awarded the full figure in their notice.
In 43 cases the rent stayed where it was, and in 20 the tribunal set it below what the tenant was already paying.
Outcomes varied by region. Landlords in the North asked for a median 15.4% and were awarded 9.4%. In the Southern region, covering the South East and South West outside London, they asked for 8.0% and were awarded 3.0%. London landlords asked for 8.1% and were awarded 5.6%.
Hello Neighbour itemises a number of pitfalls behind landlord failures:
Paperwork. Thirty-one cases failed before the tribunal considered the rent at all, and 20 of them were in London, around one in seven London cases against one in twenty elsewhere. The most common error was a new rent that did not start at the beginning of a rental period.
Other notices were served on the old Form 4 rather than Form 4A, gave less than two months’ notice, left a joint tenant off the form, were sent by email without the tenant’s agreement, or fell foul of the 52-week rule, in one Newham case by a single day.
–
Thin evidence. Tribunals decide almost every case on paper and are entitled to use their own knowledge of local rents. Only 73 of the 300 figures were built directly from named comparables, and in 53 cases the panel had no usable evidence in front of it. Advertised rents or portal price guides were put forward in 247 decisions, achieved lettings in only 139.
The most frequent reason evidence was discounted was a missing address, date or supporting detail (131 times), followed by comparables of a different size or type (117) and asking rents put forward in place of rents actually achieved (64). In about seven in ten decisions the comparables carried no floor areas.
–
The wrong kind of ‘achieved’ rent. Several panels gave little weight to rents agreed at renewal by sitting tenants. In Rochdale a tribunal preferred the landlord’s own lower adverts for identical flats, noting that sitting tenants tend to accept increases “being fearful of losing their home”. In Watford a landlord’s AI-generated rent estimate was given limited weight.
–
Asking too little. In 43 cases the tribunal judged the market rent to be higher than the landlord had proposed but could not award more than the figure in the notice. In Preston the landlord’s own agent had advised £900 a month; the landlord asked for £725, the tribunal assessed the market rent at £900, and the rent was capped at £725.
–
Rents can go down as well as up. A section 13 notice invites a market valuation in both directions. Of the 20 tenants who ended up paying less, five did so because the landlord submitted no evidence at all. In Southwark a furnished flat in Elephant and Castle fell from £2,560 to £2,350 a month on seven nearby listings put in by the tenant.
–
Delay. The median time from notice to decision was 109 days. The new rent is not backdated, so a weak first submission costs months at the old rent.
Hardship arguments rarely changed the outcome. Tenants asked for the start date to be deferred in 168 decisions and 10 were granted. Hardship cannot change the amount of rent, only delay its start by up to two months.
–
Richard Jenkins, chief executive and co-founder of Hello Neighbour, says: “Across England, tribunals are setting open market rents, which is what they should do, and landlords with good evidence are being awarded what they ask for.
“The problem is that most landlords arrive with a few portal screenshots, no floor areas and sometimes no evidence at all, and too many never get as far as a valuation because the notice is wrong.
“The answer is to get a detailed valuation based on achieved rents before setting the figure, and to treat the notice and the dates with the same care. The figure in the notice is the most a tribunal can award, so getting it right at the start matters.”